Aerial view of Cayo Espanto, a four-acre private island with seven villas tucked among palm trees, surrounded by turquoise Caribbean water
Stays

Baby's first vacation: the case for a private island

Four acres, seven villas, eighteen guests at capacity; why Cayo Espanto was the right call with a baby, and what it actually costs.

The genesis of The Cool Mom was centered around a single, nagging question that set on almost immediately after I gave birth to my son: how could I continue to live my life pre-kid in the same way post-kid? I felt strongly that - as a mother - I should continue to travel, eat, and generally go on adventures without feeling like I was making compromises. That said, I also recognized that certain trips and restaurants were likely better suited for different age groups. And then, I found Cayo Espanto, a private island in Belize that is everything I could ask for - as a mom, as a daughter, and generally, as a human.

Why a private island, specifically

I understand the eye-rolling that may come with a recommendation that includes the words “private island.” But pick the right one, and it is not only accessible (in more ways than one), but also infinitely more convenient than just about any other alternative. An island solves problems a stretch of mainland coast does not. Everything is contained. The water is calm. And a resort small enough to know your name tends to go further for a family than one processing four hundred check-ins a day.

Cayo Espanto is four acres, three miles off San Pedro. It has seven villas that house 18 guests at absolute capacity. There is no lobby to cross, no pool deck to claim a chair on at seven in the morning, no other family’s vacation happening at the volume of your own.

The villa is the draw

Every villa comes with a private dock and a private pool, and when you’re traveling with your baby, husband, and parents (as we were), that is a luxury that you will quickly come to cherish. Want to splash about the beach? Take a few steps outside. Prefer to relax in some fresh water? Take a dip in the plunge pool. It also means that baby’s nap can happen on their (or their grandparents’) schedule, and that if there are 4 am wake-ups, you don’t feel the need to apologize to anyone but yourself.

A villa's deck and plunge pool under a pergola, its private dock in the foreground and the sea beyond

A villa's private plunge pool under a pergola, the dock and the sea beyond

The villas were recently redone in a tropical-meets-Moroccan register: Tadelakt plaster on the shower walls and vanities, new fixtures, blues and whites and wicker, an indoor-outdoor layout that keeps the water in your peripheral vision at nearly all times. It is beautiful. It is also, for what it is worth, mostly hard surfaces and open edges, which reads differently when you are the one crawling along behind him.

Casa Ventanas, the overwater villa, standing on stilts above clear turquoise water with its own deck

Inside Casa Ventanas: a bedroom with a glass floor panel, opening onto the deck and the sea

A villa bedroom with blue shutters and a canopy bed, the bathroom just through the door

The food is simply spectacular

Before you arrive, the island sends a questionnaire: preferences, dietary needs, favorite snacks. The chef takes it from there. There is no restaurant and no menu; your houseman brings what you want, where you want it.

Banana pancakes with powdered sugar, breakfast on the island

For an adult this reads as indulgence. With a baby it is closer to infrastructure. Breakfast on your own dock at the hour your kid actually wakes up, rather than the hour a dining room opens, removes the single hardest logistical problem of a resort vacation with a small child.

The houseman

Each villa gets a houseman, 24 hours, assigned to you and nobody else. This is the amenity that makes the rest of the amenities almost pale in comparison.

To be clear, a houseman is not childcare, and nobody here pretends otherwise. The island’s activities are built for adults; kayaks, paddle boards, Hobie Cats, a spa casita, a gym. What the houseman is, is a person who is already looking. The smoothie that arrives before you realize that you wanted one is a small thing on an ordinary vacation. On a day when you have been holding a baby since five in the morning, it is not a small thing. In our case, by the time we got to our villa, our wonderful houseman had already set up a crib. On day 2, he brought a play gym for our baby.

Kayaks and Hobie Cats on the sand at the water's edge

What I would tell you to bring

A pop-up tent with real UPF, which bought us a two-hour nap on sand. A hip-seat carrier rather than a stroller; a stroller on a beach is a thought experiment, not a plan. And an insulated bag with an ice pack, which held milk cold for six hours and quietly resolved the question I had been losing sleep over for a month.

He laughed, he splashed, and he was entirely unbothered by every single thing I had catastrophized. That is usually how it goes. The preparation is not wasted, exactly. It is just that the preparation is for you.

Before you book

  • Book it if: you want a splurge that does the work — a private island where the logistics disappear and the villa is the whole trip.
  • The villa to book: Casa Ventanas, the overwater one, if it’s free; any beachfront villa if it isn’t.
  • From: $2,295 a night per villa — that’s Casa Ventanas, Jun 1–Dec 16; $2,395 in winter/spring and $3,295 over the holidays. Meals and drinks are part of it, before 9% tax and a 15% resort fee. Four-night minimum.
  • Book early: there are only seven villas, and eighteen guests is the whole island.
  • With a kid: a villa with a pool and a dock, a monitor for the evenings, and pack light on wheels — the sand doesn’t do strollers. With a baby’s worth of gear, the helicopter earns its keep.
  • Getting there: water taxi from San Pedro (SPR), or helicopter direct from Belize City (BZE) to the island’s helipad. We took the water taxi and loved it.

Photos courtesy of Cayo Espanto.